My colleague Prakash Kashwan posted this image with the following accompaning text: "Jane Goodal brand of personality-cult-driven conservation has nothing to do with any kind of indigenous wisdom about conservation." In response I posted the following comment:
"I agree fully. This gives me a flashback to the early 90s. I was teaching a course on human rights and indigenous peoples at Univ. Zurich, and at the end of each spring semester the whole class moved to Geneva to sit in on the ongoing annual meetings of the UN's Working Group on Indigenous Peoples. Fascinating deliberations! But what really fascinated me was how northern indigenous peoples, esp. in North America, had seemingly already then managed to set the agenda for how to talk, argue and behave. They all talked about "mother Earth" and "elders" and "indigenous knowledge", and how indigenous wisdom could and should teach the rest of the world how to manage natural resources in a wise and sustainable way.
"To pinpoint is, and thereby risking that any indigenous peoples reading this will throw a fit and banish me altogether, I will suggest that, in the good old days, when indigenous peoples (and minorities generally) lived in harmony with nature, they did so because they lived at way below carrying capacity. There were simply not enough people around to screw up the environment. The accordingly did not need Jane Goodall type philosophies.
"While this was mostly invented, or else diffused from the more powerful centers of the world's indigenous political activity and consciousness raising, and in turn adopted by indigenous peoples on the margins (certainly geographically), we should ask ourselves if this was - still is, and maybe increasingly so - a factor that has contributed to building the today near-global network of indigenous peoples. If so, the misunderstanding about traditional peoples' relationship with nature, and the invention of such values, should perhaps not be wholly thrown out?"
Below is a summary of comments on this post (Note 4).
1d - Sacred Source Medicine - This post is to reiterate and support the prophecies of First Nations and Indigenous
people around the world... it does not matter who says it ... the prophecies are NO LESS or LESS TRUE.... educate
yourselves before you make comments and ask yourself what is the intention ... stop criticizing and judging who is
saying what. Jane Goodall has done a LIFE TIME of immense work to protect a species that has/was being killed for
profit ... she has a greater understanding than most on why we need to being conscious of how and what we do ... and
especially how it affects every living thing.... she holds NO racist views...so ask yourself... what have you done
for the world ... the people around you and what gives you the right to sit behind a computer or phone and judge
... any further negative comments on this meme you will be deleted and banned !
4d - Wish we had done that!
4d - Ana Trentini - That’s is Jane Goodall for you...most Indigenous Tribes in our continent think of how their actions
would affect the land and people...our governments only believe in exploitation...so sad.
3d - Sacred Source Medicine - Ana there are those that will sit and complain and criticize what others do... those that
don’t do should not criticize those that do...
3d - Sacred Source Medicine - Fpocus on what we want in the world.. not what we don't want
5d - Dedication of one's life to Self realization and succeeding in this very life time liberates past seven generations!
(1) This article is based on a discussion on Facebook in early April 2018
(2) Image credit: Sacred Source Medicine, URL: https://web.facebook.com/SacredSourceMedicine
(3) About the image: Sacred Source Medicine likely borrowed this image from an unknown source, without giving ... . As of around mid-April 2019, the post had received 25 comments and 19K shares.
(4) The latter "d" is short for "days", that is, number of days a comments was posted after the original post.
(5) Permalink: https://devblog.no/en/article/indigenous-peoples-and-environment
(6) This article was posted 9 April 2019. It was updated 13 April 2019.